Virginia Tech
There were two major challenges I encountered in preparing this finding aid. The first challenge was simply determining which of several different versions of Cason’s life story were correct, a question which I was unable to fully resolve. The second challenge was deciding how to describe the letters his fellow officers had written him. As the natural order of the letters provides minimal value to researchers looking at the finding aid, I chose to prepare an alphabetical index to the letter writers, thus enabling researchers who are interested in the other officers to find relevant materials easily.
This finding aid was mostly straightforward to prepare, although — as the diary was originally presumed to have been in Hawkins’ hand — the realization that the notebook postdated its contents by several decades precipitated additional research into Hawkins, leading to the discovery of several non-overlapping diaries (and a letter in Hawkins’ own hand which is very similar to the one transcribed in the volume held by Virginia Tech!) in the Pearce Civil War Collection.
For the George M. Parker papers, the challenge lay in sorting and arranging the collection, which arrived without any order. I decided to divide the collection into series according to both conceptual and practical considerations, and put the material in chronological order within the series as much as possible while keeping logical units together.
Bodleian Library, Oxford University
All finding aids in the Western Manuscript Section’s Single Items Catalogue.
The greatest challenge in preparing this finding aid was in identifying the sources of the various items copied into the volume. In most cases, Hughes provided sufficient clues to his sources for me to locate the works in the ESTC, and in many cases textual comparison of the various editions on EEBO enabled me to identify the exact edition.
This collection was fairly straightforward to catalogue, although several of the names were difficult to establish, requiring reference to a nineteenth century edition of Burke’s Peerage, or, in some cases, ultimately frustrating my attempts to establish the name.
Besides the challenge of reading Palmer’s handwriting, which left something to be desired in terms of legibility, the difficulty with this finding aid was deciding what level of detail was appropriate for this finding aid. Since I wanted to preserve the chronological ordering (within each series), and a full item-level description would have missed the forest for the trees, I ultimately decided to provide item-level descriptions only for those items of particular significance: those letters mentioning William Blake, and those letters for which a published edition was available.